| Lodge | # | Recipient Name | Year |
| Cuwe | 1 | Robert S. Henderson | 1940 |
| Migisi Opawgan | 2 | George A. Mozealous | 1948 |
| Jibshe-Wanagan | 3 | Herman Brandmiller | 1956 |
| Migisi Opawgan | 4 | Richard W. Marshall | 1952 |
| Migisi Opawgan | 5 | Henry Vassel | 1956 |
| Migisi Opawgan | 6 | Otto Hornung | 1961 |
| Munhacke | 7 | Dan Ling | 1961 |
| Tittabawasink | 8 | H. Jack Beamish | 1965 |
| Allohak | 9 | David W. Snyder | 1973 |
| Chippewa | 10 | Lonnie Bone | 1975 |
| Allohak | 11 | Robert J. Bradshaw | 1977 |
| Indian Drum | 12 | Gerald J. Bisson | 1979 |
| Allohak | 13 | Dale J. Apley, Jr | 1983 |
| Chippewa | 14 | William Fortier | 1986 |
| Nacha Tindey | 15 | Ted L Johnson | 1986 |
| Gabe-Shi-Win-Gi-Ji-Kens | 16 | Steven R. Rogers | 1986 |
| Gabe-Shi-Win-Gi-Ji-Kens | 17 | Robert E. Thibault, II | 1986 |
| Allohak | 18 | Daniel J. Feigelson | 1988 |
| Michigonong | 19 | John Foltz | 1988 |
| Allohak | 20 | Robert D. Hath | 1988 |
| Indian Drum | 21 | Timothy M. Snellenberger | 1988 |
| Migisi Opawgan | 22 | Al Christoph | 1990 |
| Cuwe | 23 | Jack Shumaker | 1992 |
| Teetonkah | 24 | Skip Van Bloem | 1992 |
| Indian Drum | 25 | Arthur D. Stevens | 1992 |
| Manitous | 26 | Josh Feigelson | 1996 |
| Manitous | 27 | Phillip M. Dullock | 1998 |
| Michigonong | 28 | Marcus Haubenstricker | 1998 |
| Migisi Opawgan | 29 | Sam Stocker | 2004 |
| Migisi Opawgan | 30 | Thomas H. Fitzgibbons | 2009 |
| Gabe-Shi-Win-Gi-Ji-Kens | 31 | Benjamin L. Stilwill | 2009 |
| Noquet | 32 | Bradford Charles Lichota | 2012 |
| Noquet | 33 | Brian Chrzanowski | 2015 |
| Noquet | 34 | John Martin “Marty” Opthoff | 2015 |
| Noquet | 35 | Charles Coutteau | 2020 |
| Noquet | 36 | Shawn Knight | 2020 |
| Agaming Maangogwan | 37 | Richard A. Todd | 2020 |
| Mishigami | 38 | Kirk Sheren | 2021 |
